Mingpu MINGPU LIGHT & SIMPLE

Quality in financial due diligence: from engagement scope to report review

Financial due diligence · Mergers and acquisitions · Quality control

A standard information request can serve several deals. Questions about customer retention and cash available at closing require different evidence. Buyers can test the quality of diligence at three points: scoping the engagement, reviewing the fieldwork and challenging the findings before delivery.

An investment committee may receive two detailed reports and still struggle to compare them. One measures customer growth by contract value, the other by collections. One flags exceptions on the first page, the other in an appendix. Consistent definitions and reporting practices help the committee work out how much of a difference comes from the businesses themselves and how much comes from the diligence method.

Put the deal assumptions in the scope

Suppose the buyer's valuation assumes that major customers will keep ordering. An instruction to “analyse revenue” could produce an accurate reconciliation without answering the retention question. Specify which customers and periods to cover and which records will distinguish renewals, churn and one-off orders.

Cash reconciliations and revenue-to-collections analysis lend themselves to common procedures. For matters specific to pricing the deal, agree at the outset how evidence will be gathered, whom the team can interview and when findings are due. If the seller restricts customer contact, agree on alternative records and explain what conclusions those records can support.

Agree on how the scope can change. The first week of work may reveal that distributors account for most sales, while the original scope covers only direct customers. Does the buyer need evidence of sales to end customers? Who holds channel inventory data, and how will the extra work affect delivery? Record the decision and its rationale so readers know which questions the evidence addresses.

Make key calculations reproducible

Customer concentration depends on how customers are grouped. An analysis by billing entity can give a different answer from one that combines entities under common control. If the buyer wants to quantify revenue at risk from losing a purchasing group, document the basis for grouping, the period, the revenue denominator and any difference between the detailed data and the general ledger. A second adviser should be able to reproduce the figure from the underlying records.

Risk lists drawn from earlier engagements help identify gaps. For each relevant item, document what the team tested, which exceptions it found and how it resolved them. A reviewer can then see why the issue warranted attention and whether new evidence justifies changing the initial assessment.

Bring sector experience into fieldwork and review

At Mingpu, we distinguish risks common to many engagements from those specific to a sector. Gaps between revenue and collections merit scrutiny across industries. In chain retail, the question may turn on customer prepayments, redemptions and refunds. In project-based software, acceptance milestones and implementation staff time may matter more. Contract terms and operating records determine where a sector checklist should lead to additional work.

Responsibilities matter, too. The adviser reconciling transaction detail may spot an exception first, while the engagement lead understands the valuation assumptions. Choose a finding that could affect the valuation and have its preparer walk a reviewer from the source data to the conclusion. A colleague with sector experience can then challenge the interpretation. This helps establish whether the data support a finding or point to a question that still needs testing.

Review findings that could change the buyer's decision

For each material finding, ask where the evidence came from, what other explanations fit and what action the buyer can take. A major customer's orders may fall because it changed its purchasing schedule or because the target lost a share of its business. Subsequent orders can help distinguish between them. A single management interview provides limited support.

Keep the verified facts, potential effects on valuation or closing, and outstanding evidence together in the report. If the impact cannot yet be quantified, identify the record needed, the person responsible and the last date on which the information can inform the decision. The buyer can take that finding directly into negotiations.

← Back to Mingpu Insights